2 September 2010

Google DNS – Not Proving to Be ‘All That’

So I have been testing Google DNS server with the new tool that they just released. It might be early days, but it ain’t as fast as the alternatives for me.

Namebench

Google released a new software tool today called namebench for Mac, Linux and Windows. This nifty little tool performs a number of lookups against a number of DNS servers and gives you a measure of the different servers that you could us. It’s a simple and basic tool:


Caption Text.

Caption Text.(Click for a full size image)

Its all about performance

Google is having a push on performance at the moment. And rightly so. Many of the biggest websites are very slow to load, either because of bloat by Adobe Flash and various adverts or because they haven’t spent a lot of time on performance and optimization.

For this website, my monitoring tells me that I am averaging between 700-800 milliseconds for the load of my home page. Lets say that is is less than a second. But to load some of the American news sites can take ten or twenty.

Google is also getting behind HTML 5 for the same reason. It’s faster and uses less network. And the network is still the slowest part of the Internet.

My results

Herewith are my results for my home Internet connection. As you can see, OpenDNS is the big winner here. Probably because they have IP Anycast with DNS servers located in London (at a guess because the traceroute isn’t very clear where the final hop is).

Anyway, click on the pictuer for large image.


Caption Text.

Caption Text.(Click for a full size image)

Please rate this post:

1 Star - It\\\'s Crud2 Stars - It\\\'s Tosh3 Stars - Something\\\'s missing4 Stars - Needs works5 Stars - Good Enough6 Stars - Good7 Stars - Excellent8 Stars - Brilliant9 Stars - Astonishing10 Stars - Awesomely Godlike? (1 votes, average: 10.00 out of 10)
Loading ... Loading ...

About Greg Ferro
Greg is a Network and Security Architect / Designer / Engineer working freelance in the UK and worked for Resellers, DotCom's, Large Corporate's and Service Providers across a variety of products & Vendors. He prefers to work for end users, believes in the life cycle, total cost of ownership and that near enough is often good enough. He likes talking about himself in the first person to feel "royal", even when hosting the Packet Pushers Podcast on Data Networking. More about Greg at http://etherealmind.com/who-am-i/ and you can follow him on Twitter.

Comments

  1. Zed says:

    OpenDNS is faster than googleDNS for me regardless of ISP (from Sydney, AU)

  2. I noticed you changed the namebench default of 200 tests to only include 10 of them. While the results may be the same, 10 is hardly statistically significant. You should try for at least 150 and post the results here.

  3. Швея says:

    Мдааа… :) Вы бы знали что про Вас пишут в других блогах :)

Trackbacks

  1. [...] с помощью фирменной утилиты от Google namebench. Как видно из теста выиграл OpenDNS. Google DNS оказался только на третьем [...]

Speak Your Mind

*